Undeclared Work in the European Moving Sector: €500M–€1B Annual Losses

October 9, 2025

FEDEMAC presented the views of European movers at the European Labour Authority (ELA) seminar on undeclared work in the moving sector on September 26. Representing FEDEMAC were President Bertil Durieux and Board Member Dana Dascalu. Belgium’s perspective was brought by Hilaire Willems, General Advisor at SIIS, who presented the Belgian Plan for Fair Competition as a model for Europe.

Members’ input at the heart of the debate

FEDEMAC’s survey, conducted in July–August 2025, gathered responses from 14 countries across Western, Northern and Eastern Europe. FEDEMAC thanks the national associations and member companies for their contributions. The message was unanimous: 100% of respondents identified undeclared work, ghost companies, tax evasion and subcontracting abuses as significant problems in their markets.

Durieux stressed the scale of the problem:

“From Belgium to Bulgaria, from Spain to Sweden – no country is immune. We estimate the total European damage to be between €500 million and €1 billion per year. The problem is not a lack of rules, but that compliance with existing rules is insufficiently enforced.”

A sector under pressure – common challenges

Beyond social fraud, members highlighted three pressing challenges:
Labour shortages – particularly severe in Austria, Germany, Sweden, Luxembourg, UK, Finland and Belgium, creating recruitment and retention difficulties.
Uneven digital transformation – with significant gaps in Bulgaria, Poland and Italy, causing unequal competitiveness.
Cost & sustainability pressures – rising wages, fuel prices, and decarbonisation demands against already tight margins.

East–West divide in fraud sophistication

FEDEMAC’s study revealed the same problems across Europe, but with different levels of sophistication:

  • Western Europe (scores 5.5–9.0): fraud schemes are complex, often using platforms and so-called “bedroom brokers.”
  • Eastern Europe (scores 3.5–4.5): fraud is more direct, relying on undeclared work and rule violations.

This East–West sophistication gradient underscores that while fraud is universal, enforcement must adapt to regional realities.

Belgium as a case study

Belgium provided a powerful example, presented by Hilaire Willems, General Advisor at SIIS. The Belgian moving sector loses an estimated €50–65 million annually to fraud – equal to 15–20% of turnover.
Breakdown of losses:

  • False self-employment: €15–20M
  • Undeclared work: €25–30M
  • Social dumping: €10–15M
  • Platform fraud: €8–12M

According to Willems:

“The Belgian moving sector loses €50–65 million annually due to fraud – that’s 15–20% of the sector’s total turnover. But our structured Plan for Fair Competition shows results: 40% more inspections, €12 million in recovered contributions and a 15% decrease in new fraud cases.”

The Belgian model distinguishes four pillars: prevention, detection, inspection and sanctions, with 31 concrete measures over 42 months. Innovative tools such as real-time data matching and predictive analytics make traditional fraud methods increasingly difficult.

If one relatively small Member State sustains such losses, the EU-wide impact of €500M–€1B annually becomes undeniable. Belgium’s Plan for Fair Competition was showcased as a blueprint for Europe.

The root cause: Enforcement failure

Despite adequate legislation in most Member States, enforcement proves dramatically deficient. A Dutch respondent summarised:

“The problem is not a lack of rules, but that compliance with existing rules is insufficiently enforced.”

Too often, compliant companies are penalised, while offenders operate unchecked. Survey respondents rated enforcement effectiveness at only 20–30%. FEDEMAC is not seeking new regulations, but proper implementation of those already in force.

Cooperation gaps

While legislation exists in almost all Member States, cooperation between authorities is rare and fragmented.

Only 3 out of 14 countries (21%) reported having structured cooperation mechanisms in place. That leaves 79% of countries with major cooperation gaps. Even more striking: 11 out of 14 countries expressed openness to EU-level coordination, showing strong willingness for change. And 100% of respondents confirmed that cross-border fraud issues cannot be solved nationally – they require a European response.

Examples of cooperation levels from members:

  • Austria, France, Spain (21%) – structured national or regional cooperation (financial police, anti-illegal work agreements, labour inspection).
  • Germany, Luxembourg, Italy, UK, Sweden (36%) – partial or pilot cooperation, but no systematic approach.
  • Romania, Poland, Bulgaria, Netherlands, Finland, Belgium (43%) – minimal or no cooperation in practice.

This cooperation gap analysis underlines the problem: rogue movers exploit national silos with ease. Without permanent EU-led inspection teams and digital interoperability between national systems, compliant movers remain exposed to unfair competition.

FEDEMAC’s call to action

FEDEMAC used the seminar to issue a strong call for action:

  • Roll-out Belgium’s Plan for Fair Competition as a model for Member States
  • Strengthen ELA’s role in coordinating inspections and enforcement
  • Enhance digital interoperability between inspection systems across borders
  • Achieve EU-wide recognition of the moving profession, comparable to the standards applied for truck drivers

Bertil Durieux closed with a strong reminder of what is at stake:

“FEDEMAC movers don’t just transport furniture – they carry families’ dreams, memories and hopes. Rogue movers turn those dreams into nightmares. The time to act has now come.”

Thanks to members

FEDEMAC warmly thanks all national associations and moving companies that contributed to the survey. Your insights allowed us to bring the real picture of the moving industry to Brussels, ensuring that policymakers heard the movers’ voice at the highest European level.